What To Do When Your Loved Ones Want You To Quit
The holidays are a wonderful time, but they can also be a difficult time for writers as we face questions (and criticism) from our friends and family. So I thought I’d update a post that I wrote almost a year ago in the hope that it will help you as much as writing it helped me. For those of you who aren’t writers, maybe it will help you understand the writer next to you a little better.
******************************************************************************
If you want to be a writer, the most difficult challenge you’re going to face isn’t writer’s block. It isn’t learning how to properly use a semi colon or write a lead or find your voice. It isn’t even getting an agent or making enough money to pay the bills.
If you want to be a writer, the most difficult challenge you’ll face comes when someone you love says one of the following things about your career:
“You need to start making better decisions.”
“It’s time you grew up and acted like a responsible adult.”
“You can still write as a hobby, but you need to get a real job.”
In her post “Are We Born to Create,” bestselling author Kristen Lamb wrote, “Many of us, when we tell our family that we want to be a writer, what they hear is akin to, ‘Blah, blah, throwing away college education blah blah cult blah Kool-Aid, blah blah writer.’”
And it hurts.
You want them to recognize how hard you work and how worthwhile your job is. More than that, you want them to be proud of you.
If they keep at it long enough or if you hear it from enough people, the pain crescendos to a level where you can’t ignore it anymore. You start to doubt yourself and the decisions you’ve made. You’re forced into doing one of two things. Either you build a protective wall around that part of your life, perhaps even your whole life, and you exclude them from it, or you give up the career you love for something more acceptable.
Neither is a good solution.
So next time you face these joy-stealing, dream-killing, confidence-shaking lies, here’s how to survive.
Remind Yourself that the World Needs Writers
When I was growing up, a lot of people pushed for me to become a veterinarian or a teacher, despite the fact that I faint at the sight of blood and don’t have the patience to deal with a roomful of children or teenagers (hey, at least I’m honest about my limitations). They told me (in not so many words) that becoming a writer was a waste of my potential. Why would I throw away my future?
The world needs writers.
Without writers, we wouldn’t have classic literature or textbooks to study. We wouldn’t have the books, journal articles, and other written resources teachers use to learn their subjects and prepare their lesson plans.
Without writers, the millions of people whose favorite pastime is curling up with a book or magazine would have to fall back on watching TV or movies . . . except that without writers, we wouldn’t have TV shows or movies.
Without writers, politicians would become a lot less eloquent. (You don’t really think they write their speeches themselves, do you?)
Without writers, both print and online newspapers would have no content.
Without writers charities and non-profits wouldn’t be able to get their message out and bring in the funds they need to help people.
Without writers, we’d have to revert to preserving all the new advances in knowledge through oral traditions. Any student of history will tell you what a flawed method that is.
Ask for Clarification on What It Means to Have a Real Job
Some well-meaning relatives may go so far as to suggest you should have gotten a job at a fast food place long ago. I believe that all law-abiding work is honorable, but don’t understand why a minimum-wage job is a “real job” while writing isn’t. What does having a “real job” mean?
Does it mean helping people?
After publication of an article that Lisa Hall-Wilson and I co-wrote on pornography addiction, we received an email thanking us and telling us that we might have saved a marriage. It’s not the only thank you email I’ve received. My words make a difference.
Does it mean fighting traffic?
Seems to me that telecommuting and home offices are a growing trend because people don’t want to fight traffic, burn increasingly expensive gas, and worry about bad weather.
Does it mean someone else needs to sign your paychecks?
Someone else does sign my checks. And I’ll let you in on a secret—those paychecks bring in more than I could ever make from a minimum-wage job.
Does it mean putting on a tie, or khakis and a polo shirt/blouse, or a uniform?
I could put those on to sit at home if I really wanted, though I’m not sure why I would when I can work in sweats.
Does it mean having the respect of clients and colleagues?
If you’re professional, you can build good relationships, a good reputation, and develop regular clients regardless of your job title. I’ve earned enough respect in my field to teach at conferences and judge writing contests.
Find Some Allies
This world will always have people who feel that they know better than you what you should do with your life. It’ll always have people who find it easy to judge you for your choices even though they’ve never been in your position. It’ll always have people who draw attention to your failures and weaknesses rather than your successes and strengths.
Find yourself some people who’ll call you out on evil rather than on personal preference, who have your back, and who will fight harder for you than you do for yourself. You need the support. Even Batman had Robin and Superman had Lois Lane.
Keep In Mind Who You Really Need to Please
When it comes right down to it, other people’s opinions don’t matter. You have to make your own decisions and follow your own conscience. You are accountable only to God.
So have a good cry and some chocolate. Realize that it’s always going to sting. And then pick yourself up off the floor, sit your bottom back down in your computer chair, and meet that deadline . . . and the one after that . . . and the one after that . . .
Are you following your dream or did you give it up because your friends or family didn’t approve? Are you a writer who’s faced some of these criticisms? How did you handle it?
Interested in more ways to improve your writing? Point of View in Fiction is now available. (You also might want to check out Internal Dialogue or Showing and Telling in Fiction.) All are available in both print and ebook.
Image Credit: freeimages.com/Kiomi
Dec 19, 2011 @ 10:02:23
Great post! One of the things that I’ve realized lately is that the people who discourage my writing are the people who are unhappy in their own careers, or some area of their lives. If I can go after what I want and make changes in my life then they start to feel pressure to do something about theirs. It’s like we broke the silent code to pretend that everything was alright. So, I choose to spend my time around people who support me and my writing. And yes that includes family, too.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 19:45:09
I think you’ve really hit on it. If a person has given up their own dreams or have chosen a path because it’s safe, they often feel uncomfortable seeing someone else take the riskier path they were too frightened to take.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 10:25:12
Lots of good stuff here, Marcy. Most loved ones suggest we get a “real job” because they believe (rightly or wrongly) that writing won’t make us prosperous. This situation needs to be handled directly. If we are prosperous as writers, we should tell them that. If we’re not, maybe we should consider their loving concern and figure out how to deal with prosperity. Any suggestions for how to do that?
Dec 19, 2011 @ 22:34:28
I think it comes down to what each of us wants out of life. If we’re happy living a simpler life in order to be able to do what we love, then that’s a form of prosperity as well. Not everyone wants European vacations or fancy homes or the ability to eat out all the time. For some, a cozy home, hearty, home-cooked meals, and peace are the essence of prosperity.
If we’re not happy with a simpler life and writing isn’t allowing us to live the life we want (i.e., we’re not prosperous even by our own definition), then we’ll need to either find writing work that isn’t our first choice but pays better (like corporate writing) or write as a second job.
I think whatever the choice is, the key is to let our loved ones know that we appreciate their concern, but that we know what we have a plan and that we’ll let them know if we need help/advice.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 11:30:50
Marcy, I just printed this post to hang in my office!!
Thank you! 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 19:45:27
That made my day 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 11:57:14
Thank you, Marcy. It is even difficult when you do work a “real job”. I do my writing on my days off and in the evenings after my “real job,” so I’m not available to make phone calls, go to dinner, and do other ‘bonding’ activities. Some people do not understand, won’t ever understand. All you can do is say ‘thank you for your concern, I’m very happy with my life,’ and get back in the chair and write away. 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 20:36:20
“I’m happy with my life.”
Exactly. We all make decisions about what to spend our time on, and it’s not going to be the same for everyone.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 12:32:41
Thanks, Marcy. Sometimes the doubters make us doubt ourselves. My closest friends and family are supportive (especially after they see 1. that I’m actually writing, and 2. that what I’m writing is not totally garbage), but I get lots–lots–of eye-rolling and smirks.
Your post is so spot-on.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 22:10:40
Thanks 🙂 I’ve noticed that I get fewer raised eyebrows from people who’ve actually read what I’ve written as well. I think some people can come around in time, and others we just have to learn how to deal with because they’ll never really get it.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 14:49:41
Awesome post Marcy! Thanks for re-posting this.
I think the worst comments don’t come from someone else, but from ourselves when we’re ready to give up.
You inspired me today to keep going! 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 20:42:52
I’m very glad to hear that, Karen 🙂 Self-doubt can be tough to fight, and sometimes we just need someone to say, “I’ve been there too. Don’t give up.”
Dec 19, 2011 @ 15:01:48
I remember this post, hun. I hope you haven’t forgotten that I’ve always had your back, and will continue to have your back in your writing endeavours. I may not understand your choice of career, but I’ll always support it.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 20:43:33
I am very blessed that my husband does support me 100% 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 16:28:20
Awesome post Marcy! That’s probably why I stayed quiet for so long. But my family has been very supportive. I’ve been lucky that way. And I’m finding new friends to bond with. 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 22:11:58
I have a core group of very supportive people in my life too. Some of them I’ve known for years, some I’ve met at writer’s conferences, and others I’ve online. Allies can make all the difference 🙂
Dec 19, 2011 @ 16:59:39
It’s the passion for writing that keeps us going despite what other people might say. Without the passion, we’d chose other careers to be passionate about. I worked as an accountant for years and loved what I did. On Sunday night, I couldn’t wait till Monday morning so I could get to work. Now, I’ve chosen to put that passion into my writing.
Wonderful post, Marcy!
Dec 19, 2011 @ 22:16:37
Thanks, Sheila 🙂 I’m the kind of person who believes that everyone needs to find a job they love and are passionate about. We invest such a large portion of our lives into our careers. I find it sad if we can’t find at least some joy in what we do.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 17:32:09
I truly appreciate the inspiration boost. Every now and again everyone needs one to continue writing. The majority of my family have no idea that I am writing because of what I’m writing. I am fortunate to have the support of my husband and children and that’s all that matters at this time. My writings have healed me and will hopefully help heal the wounds of others that have gone through the same ordeals.
That hot chocolate and marshmellows sounds really good right about now.
Thank you!
Dec 19, 2011 @ 22:22:03
My husband is my biggest supporter as well. On the really rough days, it makes all the difference to know I have him to lean on.
And sometimes you have to take the time to just write without anyone else knowing. It can give you the freedom to put down on paper what needs to be there without fear. When the time is right, you’ll tell the rest of your family.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 20:04:08
This is beautiful, Marcy. I feel so blessed to have parents and a hubby who embrace what I do. I’ve certainly encountered the opposite…and it’s crushing. I’m going to bookmark this and pass it on to friends dealing with such naysayers.
Dec 19, 2011 @ 22:22:49
Thanks 🙂 I hope it will help them hold their heads a little higher.
Dec 20, 2011 @ 00:40:49
thanks for an encouraging post, Marcy. I am my harshest critic, with an inner dialogue that occasionally goes to ‘unlucky’, ‘untalented’ etc etc. it’s good to have the reminder that none of this is true.
I do have a day job. and it is full time, but I choose to live my life on my terms and that means sitting in front of my computer most evenings.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 22:02:23
It can be just as difficult for people who have a full-time job doing something else because friends/family often don’t understand why so many hours need to be put into something that to them is “just another hobby.” Good for you for ignoring the discouraging voices in your head and pressing on 🙂
Dec 20, 2011 @ 01:32:22
This is such a fantastic post, Marcy, and I’m so happy that you’ve reposted it. I’m not in the position to write full time, so I am pulling the balancing act of the day job vs. the “hobby” that I have started to treat as a job. One of the reasons I went with a pen name was because I didn’t want to deal with colleagues or superiors in my work life making assumptions about the fact that I am juggling academia and novel-writing. Rationally, I know that I should be able to do whatever I want when I’m not at work, but the last thing I need is for someone to google me and find hits for my novels, rather than my journal articles or non-fiction texts.
When it comes to my personal life, I’m lucky to have family that is incredibly supportive of my choice to juggle. I’ve been writing ever since I was a kid, and my mom always told me not to give up on my dream of being published. They’re the cheerleaders that keep me going, and I’m really grateful to them for encouraging me onward.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 22:18:18
Lisa Hall-Wilson and I both considered using pen names for a similar reason. Our full-time writing is for mainly Christian magazines, newspapers, and non-profits, but the novel we’re writing is a historical fantasy for the general market. We were a little worried about trying to balance the two because we didn’t want people to confuse our non-fiction work with our fiction work. Although we ended up sticking with our names, it wasn’t an easy decision, and so I definitely understand your choice 🙂
I’m really glad you’re backed by some good cheerleaders 🙂
Dec 20, 2011 @ 11:28:42
This post really hit home. My husband and friends are supportive but underneath being nice they’re doubting me. I’m doubting my abilities to write something worth publishing too so I don’t tell them much. That’s what writing buddies are for for now. I’m saving this great advice for future need.
PS. This was my first visit to your site, Marcy, and I was totally blown away. Your site looks really professional and gorgeous and I loved your other blog posts too.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 22:33:01
I find the online community of writers I’m part of to be a huge encouragement as well.
Thank you so much for the compliment about my site and my blog 🙂 I worked with a very talented pair of web designers to put this site together because, while I can string together words, I can’t write code. I’m very grateful to them for helping me create a site I love 🙂
Dec 20, 2011 @ 15:07:35
Aw, I’m sorry you had negative people to contend with. I’m so blessed to have a family that supports me, no matter if I’m published or not. They are my spiritual cheerleaders and believe in what I’m doing.
Keep being positive!
Dec 21, 2011 @ 22:34:41
Thanks, Tameri 🙂 I don’t know if you noticed the comment from my husband above, but he is a huge support to me. He helps offset some of the negatives by always cheering me on.
Dec 23, 2011 @ 16:39:15
Marcy, I noticed the comment from your hubby and I think it’s WONDERFUL. I’ve got a cheerleading hubby myself and it makes a world of difference.
Dec 23, 2011 @ 22:50:32
It makes all the difference in the world some days 🙂
Dec 21, 2011 @ 16:02:32
Wonderful post! Ahh, the looks I sometime get when I say I’m a writer and then they ask what books I have published. My answer is none at this moment. And they look at me with pity or surprise. And then they usually say, “oh, you mean writing is your hobby, not your job”, sigh.
I’ve been lucky with my family as there are writers among us, so they get me. But some do still have difficulty with me saying I can’t do something because that interfers with my writing time. Writing buddies are essential. We need to cheer each other along!
Dec 21, 2011 @ 22:37:07
As Kristen Lamb says, we need to call ourselves writers even if we don’t have a book for sale yet. If we treat is as a hobby, it will always be a hobby, but when we treat it as a job and give up things in order to write, then one day we’ll get there. Chin up 🙂
Dec 21, 2011 @ 16:30:54
I’m so glad you reposted this, Marcy. This is excellent and I can so relate to all of it. Yes, still dealing with that attitude, but I find support from my writer friends, online and in person. No matter what’s said, they can’t stop me from what I’m passionate about. Yes, it hurts, but it would hurt even more if I listened, took their words to heart, and let it keep me from writing. Thanks for this post!
Dec 21, 2011 @ 22:38:49
Thanks 🙂 You’re so right. It would hurt worse if we completely gave up on something we love just because others don’t understand.
The End is Near (and we deserve it). . . . Santa Loses Reindeer in Ohio « Author Piper Bayard
Dec 23, 2011 @ 08:53:07
[…] Not every author is lucky enough to have a family that supports them in their career choice. Marcy Kennedy talks about What to Do When Your Loved Ones Want You to Quit writing. […]
[WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The comment’s server IP (72.233.69.24) doesn’t match the comment’s URL host IP (72.233.69.6) and so is spam.
Dec 23, 2011 @ 09:40:53
Wow, this was really great to hear. Thanks so much for sharing it.
Dec 23, 2011 @ 09:49:36
You’re welcome 🙂
Dec 23, 2011 @ 11:04:44
Wonderful post! I’m lucky that my husband completely supports me and wants me to continue to stay home and write. He’s reading my book and offered a lot of support. Most of the doubt and guilt for not having a “real job” comes from me. I do child care but feel I should be bringing in more money and worry that all of my hard work writing, blogging, etc. will end up to be a fruitless effort financially, but you’ve reminded me that money isn’t everything. I’ve learned A LOT about myself this year simply from writing and taking part in social media.
Thanks!
Dec 23, 2011 @ 22:34:58
Part of the long-term plan my husband and I have is for me to be able to cut back on the non-fiction work that I do so that I can focus more on fiction. We don’t know when that day will come, but he’s my champion for making those plans with me.
And I’m sure you’ll get there 🙂
Dec 23, 2011 @ 13:08:38
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful post! My hubby and most of my immediate family and friends support my writing (though sometimes they forget it requires a time commitment LOL). Some of my other relatives don’t understand and are not to opposed to letting me know. I do wish they’d understand but I can’t make them. All I can do is keep working towards my dream and plugging into those that encourage me.
Dec 23, 2011 @ 22:39:23
I’m very glad to hear that those closest to you believe in you. Somehow it seems like we need two allies for every one enemy, doesn’t it?
Dec 23, 2011 @ 14:04:26
This is great, Marcy! Those lines sound very familiar. My immediate family believes that pleasing God is the only thing that really matters and they support me as a writer, but sometimes extended family doesn’t understand that. Thanks for the encouragement to keep writing!
Alina Sayre
Dec 23, 2011 @ 22:51:40
Thanks 🙂 It’s very nice to meet you, and I hope we get the chance to chat on Twitter.
Dec 23, 2011 @ 16:49:07
Marcy, there is power in believing in your dreams.
Incidentally, I was going through my old Writer’s Digests and I saw the issue where YOU won the Writer’s Digest contest and it was such a kick for me.
I went yelling through my house, “Honey, honey, LOOK. This is Marcy, one of my favorite tweeps and she won!!”
He kindly refrained from pointing out that the issue was old enough that I should have read it all ready and the two of us had quite an excited moment for you. 🙂
Dec 23, 2011 @ 22:54:07
I wish you could see my grin right now. You and other wonderful writing buddies add so many bright spots to my days that I don’t know what I ever did before. Thank you more than I can say 🙂
Some Linky Love to Bring in the New Year… | Jenny Hansen's Blog
Dec 31, 2011 @ 20:13:45
[…] of writers. Here’s two posts that have stood out ot me on the topic from Louisa Bacio and Marcy Kennedy. She wrote it long before the holidays, but Kate MacNicol’s post, Deceitful Me, continues in […]
[WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The comment’s server IP (216.151.210.25) doesn’t match the comment’s URL host IP (74.200.244.59) and so is spam.