What Groundhog Day Can Teach Us About Contentment
Important life lessons don’t usually come in the form of a large ground squirrel predicting the weather and a day that literally never ends.
But Groundhog Day, a 1993 movie starring Bill Murray, weaves three of the most important lessons for contentment around the story of a cynical weather man trapped in a time warp in Punxsutawney, PA, on February 2.
Phil Connors (Bill Murray) travels from Pittsburg with his cameraman and his producer Rita (Andie MacDowell) to report on what the groundhog says about the coming of spring. The problem is that every morning he wakes up and it’s still February 2. He’s the only one who realizes they’re trapped in a time loop.
In his attempt to keep his sanity, he—like most of us—learns the hard way the three things that will allow him to be content regardless of his circumstances.
Physical pleasures might be fun for the moment, but they often end in boredom and despair. A fulfilling life requires something more.
Once Phil’s confusion wears off, he realizes that no tomorrow means no consequences, and he can do whatever he wants. He smokes, gluts himself on coffee and pastries, steals money from the bank, and has a series of one-night stands.
And at first, he’s deliriously happy. If I’m being honest, I can relate. Imagine being able to eat all your favorite foods without gaining a pound.
It’s appealing.
And destructive.
Soon the thrill wears off for Phil. The pleasures aren’t enough, and despair takes over. He tries to kill the groundhog, thinking that might be the way out. When that fails, he tries to kill himself in every conceivable way. When that fails as well, Phil takes his first small step toward being a better person. He starts to think of others instead of just of himself.
You can’t save everyone.
One of Phil’s daily errands is trying to save an old homeless man who dies. The first night Phil finds the man collapsed, he rushes him to the hospital. The man dies anyway.
The nurse tells Phil, “Sometimes people just die.”
“Not today,” he says.
Saving the old man becomes an obsession. He feeds him, performs CPR, does everything he can think of. Nothing works. It was the man’s time to die.
It’s the saddest lesson of Groundhog Day, but one of the most important, especially for me. I take in strays. When I see someone hurting or with a problem, I want to fix it. I believe in second chances. I have a difficult time giving up on or letting go of anyone.
But sometimes you have no other choice. Sometimes you’re going to lose one. If you let that loss destroy your confidence, or cause you to stop trying, you’ll also give up the chance of helping many others. Never let losing one keep you from trying.
You can’t force or trick someone into loving you. What you can do is become the person your perfect mate would naturally fall in love with.
Early in the movie, Phil calls the woman he’s kissing by Rita’s name and figures out it’s Rita he really wants. That attraction quickly grows into love because Rita is a genuinely nice person.
Unfortunately, Phil isn’t the kind of man Rita wants. He’s the exact opposite. When the movie starts, he’s cruel and selfish and egocentric. But he doesn’t want to change, so he goes on a quest to learn everything he can about Rita in the hope of convincing her to fall in love with him (or at least sleep with him).
But no matter what tactics he tries, every evening ends with Rita slapping him. Phil eventually gives up, and not being able to win her over contributes to his depression and suicide attempts.
The turning point for him comes when he realizes he doesn’t deserve her. Instead of continuing to try to trick Rita into loving him, he works on becoming the kind of man she would fall in love with. He starts to read the classics, learns how to ice sculpt, and takes piano lessons. He spends his days running around Punxsutawney, trying to make this one day perfect for all the residents, from catching a boy who falls from a tree at the same time every day to fixing a flat tire for three old ladies. He learns to love the small town and its people.
By the end of the movie, Rita falls in love with him for who he’s become–and the time loop ends because he’s learned what it really means to love.
Have you discovered one of these lessons the hard way? The most difficult lesson of the three for me is admitting I can’t save everyone. Which is the biggest struggle for you?
If you enjoyed this post, remember to sign up below for free updates whenever I add a new post.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 09:17:44
Those are three important lessons. And I never would have thought there was an actual message in Groundhog Day! It has been so long since I’ve seen it, but I do remember laughing. I think the big lesson I have to work on is the first one. That something more. That’s what I want! Great post, Marcy!
Apr 16, 2012 @ 11:51:22
They did a really great job of entertaining rather than just trying to hit you over the head with a message. It never feels self-absorbed the way some of the newer movies do.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 09:40:35
Groundhog Day is a favorite movie in our house too.
I think a hard lesson for me is staring too long at a closed door. It’s never easy to turn away and accept something is done or over. I usually think of second chances or hope too.
Great post Marcy 🙂
Apr 16, 2012 @ 11:53:03
Turning away from a closed door is a really difficult one. I think most of us hate to give up on something we really want even if it should be clear to us that it’s not going to happen (at least not at the moment).
Apr 16, 2012 @ 10:07:35
I have to admit, I probably watch this movie once a year. I don’t know what it is about Bill Murray, but he makes me laugh, even though I know what is going to happen.
I love your breakdown of the lessons in this movie – they really are important messages and ones that most people don’t think about when it comes to this movie.
Not being able to save everyone is a big one for me, but also a variation of number three. You can’t “trick” people into liking you, either. Real friendships are built on REAL things, not just going through the motions.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 11:58:41
I think you and I are genuinely very much alike 🙂 Number three is a battle for me too. I’m a lot more comfortable with myself now, and so I’m better at letting people see the real me and either like me or not, but I think I’m always going to face that temptation. (I used the example of lopping off a chimera head in an older post.) But it’s like you said–friendships aren’t worth having if they’re not the real thing.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 11:43:33
Fabulous breakdown of the movie and its lessons. Now I want to watch the movie all over again 🙂 Great post Marcy.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 11:54:17
Thanks 🙂 I’m glad you liked it. This movie is definitely worth another watch!
Apr 16, 2012 @ 13:38:19
Great post, Marcy, and super relatable. I think learning that we can’t save others is a biggie, especially for anyone who’s been affected by addiction. Trying to save others can seem un-selfish, but the truly un-selfish act is loving them enough to speak honestly then step away.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 14:08:01
What an excellent point. When dealing with someone with an addiction, sometimes you think you’re helping but what you’re really doing is enabling. Knowing when they sincerely need your help and when you need to walk away isn’t easy. It’s a very fine line to walk and becomes especially tricky because most addicts get very good at lying to loved ones in order to keep that person without having to give up whatever they’re addicted to.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 13:57:11
I loved Groundhog Day and what I learned is how much we can accomplish if we get a do-over. I want a do-over. I could really use a week of do-overs!
Great points~
Apr 16, 2012 @ 14:04:46
I can’t tell you the number of times I would have liked a do-over 🙂 I guess the best we can do is look at every new day as a type of do-over where we can at least learn from the mistakes we made the day before even if we can’t completely erase what happened.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 14:25:21
Great post, Marcy.
Love Ground hog day and wouldn’t it be great to have a do-over? Sigh. But, as you say, onward and upward and move on.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 14:57:42
And we’d probably only enjoy the first do-over rather than day after day 🙂
Apr 16, 2012 @ 14:58:56
We love this movie. It has such a great lesson. We watch it whenever we happen to see it playing on cable. It’s like a magnet.
I can think of a few things I wouldn’t mind a do-over on. If only…
Apr 16, 2012 @ 15:50:36
I have this movie on DVD because it’s my go-to when I need a pick me up 🙂
Apr 16, 2012 @ 16:27:23
Well – I’m the black sheep again. I find this movie completely annoying. My family likes it, but I get up to do the dishes or wash laundry. To each his own, I guess 🙂 Great takeaway though – important lessons to learn.
Apr 16, 2012 @ 16:47:35
My mom doesn’t like it either. The world would be a boring place if we were all the same 🙂
Apr 16, 2012 @ 19:06:59
All three points are very very important in life. Poor old Phil Connors just took a really long time figuring them out!
What a silly movie, but good one to stress these important life lessons.
Patricia Rickrode
w/a Jansen Schmidt
Apr 16, 2012 @ 19:45:15
I guess it shows how nasty he was to start with 😀
It was a silly movie. I still laugh every time when Phil says to Rita “Do you want some blood sausage too? I have some in the glove box.” And she says, “I like blood sausage.” It’s just so cute 🙂
Apr 16, 2012 @ 21:16:53
Love this! I always thought it was a great movie, but I never looked at it this deeply to figure out why it was so good. 🙂
Apr 17, 2012 @ 21:07:10
Thanks 🙂 I’ve loved this movie for a long time too, and it was only recently that the light bulb went off in my head 🙂
Apr 16, 2012 @ 21:22:23
Marcy, great analysis of the lesson Phil learns in the movie. This is one of our favorite winter holiday movies to watch. There’s something so HEA about Phil learning to be a better man. Love it. Bill Murray did a terrific job of paying his part. 🙂
Apr 17, 2012 @ 21:21:08
I thought Bill Murray did an excellent job too 🙂 And I just recently learned that the US National Film Registry actually called Groundhog Day culturally and historically significant, which I thought was interesting because how often does a comedy get that kind of designation?
Apr 16, 2012 @ 21:53:18
My daughter and I love this movie. I’m afraid if I were given the option to do so, there is one day I would choose to live over and over. It would be worth it to spend time with loved ones who have left this world too early. As to which lessons I have the hardest time with…2 and 3.
Thanks for reminding me about Groundhog Day, Marcy. I think I may have to pay a visit to Amazon to see if it’s available on DVD. 🙂
Apr 17, 2012 @ 21:23:13
Amazon does have a copies on DVD, blueray, or for instant access download 🙂
I can understand wanting to live a day over and over again to be able to spend it with a lost loved one. I think that’d be appealing to anyway.
Apr 17, 2012 @ 03:33:32
“Physical pleasures might be fun for the moment, but they often end in boredom and despair. A fulfilling life requires something more.”
This really resonated with me. It is so easy to just do the fun things and avoid what is difficult. But if you never try your limits, you don’t grow and develop. You’ll be stuck at where you are right now. New paths require leaps of faith and venturing into the unknown.
Apr 17, 2012 @ 21:31:19
Well put. We get trapped like Phil when we refuse to grow and try our limits. A lot of what’s worth having is difficult 🙂
Apr 17, 2012 @ 18:38:46
What a cool post and insightful question. I think the one that hits home with me is that I can only change myself. And that I can’t save everyone. That’s a hard one, but if people lived forever, where would we put them all? Ah, a nice bit of introspection for this sunny Tuesday afternoon. Love it!
Apr 17, 2012 @ 21:32:54
Thanks 🙂 The really great thing is that by changing the things we find we don’t like about ourselves, we actually make life better for all the people who love us.
Apr 17, 2012 @ 19:32:15
I have to confess I’ve never been a great Bill Murray fan, but when I finally got around to seeing Groundhog Day years ago, I loved it. My favorite thing, and what makes it watchable over and over, was his process to become a decent human being. One of my “wow” moments was when I realized how long he must have been stuck there, to go from no piano knowledge to playing whatever it was that he played.
I also like the quote “Physical pleasures might be fun for the moment, but they often end in boredom and despair. A fulfilling life requires something more.” Which is why pleasure and happiness have two different meanings.
Apr 17, 2012 @ 21:41:50
I’m always in awe too of just how long this must have gone on. Even if you just think about how long it took him to learn the exact times and places he needed to be to help all those people. I think he must have been there for at least a year of days. But then change is never easy or fast, and I think the fact that it took him so long speaks authentically to just how hard we have to work sometimes to better our lives.
Link Feast Vol. 4 | Reetta Raitanen's Blog
Apr 18, 2012 @ 17:28:33
[…] What Groundhog Day (the movie) can teach us about contentment by Marcy Kennedy […]
Apr 18, 2012 @ 21:02:51
My lesson? You can’t save everyone. I can only help people along the road if they ask for help.
May 01, 2012 @ 17:56:18
“You can’t force or trick someone into loving you. What you can do is become the person your perfect mate would naturally fall in love with.”
This lesson resonates with me, because for a very long time I always lived my life trying to make people love me. I was very desperate & emotionally needy. I’m not that way now, thanks to a lot of hard work, counseling, & prescription medication. But I can never forget that lesson — learning to become the person that my perfect mate would naturally fall in love with. Once I stopped looking for someone to love me, & started loving myself & figuring out who *I* wanted to be, love fell right into my lap — & sure enough, it came naturally. Now we work together to be the best we can be, for ourselves as well as for each other.
Andi-Roo /// @theworld4realz
http://www.theworld4realz.com/
theworldforrealz@gmail.com
May 01, 2012 @ 18:00:04
I’m so glad you figured out who you wanted to be and found the person would loved you that way. My husband and I are the same and now we can work together to become better people 🙂