What To Do When Your Loved Ones Want You To Quit Your Dream
Three years ago I wrote a post called “A Writer’s Greatest Challenge.” I’m posting an updated version of it today under the title “What to Do When Your Loved Ones Want You to Quit Your Dream.”
As we start into 2014, many of you have probably committed to making this year the year your writing career takes off, or you’ve decided to finally finish your novel, or maybe you’re taking the plunge to write your very first story.
Or maybe you’re trying to decide whether to give up on your writing and move on.
What anyone who’s been writing long enough will tell you is that, as writers, we all face questions (and criticism) from our friends and family because of our choice to write. And especially if we turn our writing into a career.
A lot has changed in the three years since I originally wrote this post. The people I care about most have come to see the value in what I do (or have at least accepted that I’m not going to quit), and I’ve seen my career flourish in ways I’d never have imagined.
But I’m posting this again because writing it all those years ago was what kept me from giving up. I’m hoping reading it now will keep some of you from giving up as well.
*******************************************************************************************************************************
If you want to be a writer, the most difficult challenge you’re going to face isn’t writer’s block. It isn’t learning how to properly use a comma or write a lead or find your voice. It isn’t even getting an agent or making enough money to pay the bills.
If you want to be a writer, the most difficult challenge you’ll face comes when someone you love says one of the following things about your writing career:
“You need to start making better decisions.”
“It’s time you grew up and acted like a responsible adult.”
“You can still write as a hobby, but you need to get a real job.”
In her post “Are We Born to Create,” bestselling author Kristen Lamb wrote, “Many of us, when we tell our family that we want to be a writer, what they hear is akin to, ‘Blah, blah, throwing away college education blah blah cult blah Kool-Aid, blah blah writer.’”
And it hurts.
You want them to recognize how hard you work and how worthwhile your job is. More than that, you want them to be proud of you.
If they keep at it long enough or if you hear it from enough people, the pain crescendos to a level where you can’t ignore it anymore. You start to doubt yourself and the decisions you’ve made. You’re forced into doing one of two things. Either you build a protective wall around that part of your life, perhaps even your whole life, and you exclude them from it, or you give up the career you love for something more acceptable.
Neither is a good solution.
So next time you face these joy-stealing, dream-killing, confidence-shaking lies, here’s how to survive.
Remind Yourself that the World Needs Writers
When I was growing up, a lot of people pushed for me to become a veterinarian or a teacher, despite the fact that I faint at the sight of blood and don’t have the patience to deal with a roomful of children or teenagers (hey, at least I’m honest about my limitations). They told me (in not so many words) that becoming a writer was a waste of my potential. With my intelligence, I could do anything. Why would I throw away my future?
The world needs writers.
Without writers, we wouldn’t have classic literature or textbooks to study. We wouldn’t have the books, journal articles, and other written resources teachers use to learn their subjects and prepare their lesson plans.
Without writers, the millions of people whose favorite pastime is curling up with a book or magazine would have to fall back on watching TV or movies . . . except that without writers, we wouldn’t have TV shows or movies either.
Without writers, politicians would become a lot less eloquent. (You don’t really think they write their speeches themselves, do you?)
Without writers, both print and online newspapers would have no content.
Without writers, charities and non-profits wouldn’t be able to get their message out and bring in the funds they need to help people.
Without writers, we’d have to revert to preserving all the new advances in knowledge through oral traditions. Any student of history will tell you what a flawed method that is.
Ask for Clarification on What It Means to Have a Real Job
Some well-meaning relatives may go so far as to suggest you should have gotten a job at a fast food place long ago. I believe that all law-abiding work is honorable, but don’t understand why a minimum-wage job is a “real job” while writing isn’t. What does having a “real job” mean?
Does it mean helping people?
After publication of an article that Lisa Hall-Wilson and I co-wrote on pornography addiction, we received an email thanking us and telling us that we might have saved a marriage. It’s not the only thank you email I’ve received over the years. My words make a difference.
Does it mean fighting traffic?
Seems to me that telecommuting and home offices are a growing trend because people don’t want to fight traffic, burn increasingly expensive gas, and worry about bad weather.
Does it mean someone else needs to sign your paychecks?
Someone else does sign my checks. And I’ll let you in on a secret—those paychecks bring in more than I could ever make from a minimum-wage job.
Does it mean putting on a tie, or khakis and a polo shirt/blouse, or a uniform?
I could put those on to sit at home if I really wanted, though I’m not sure why I would when I can work in sweats.
Does it mean having the respect of clients and colleagues?
If you’re professional, you can build good relationships, a good reputation, and develop regular clients regardless of your job title.
Find Some Allies
This world will always have people who feel that they know better than you what you should do with your life. It’ll always have people who find it easy to judge you for your choices even though they’ve never been in your position. It’ll always have people who draw attention to your failures and weaknesses rather than your successes and strengths.
Find yourself some people who’ll call you out on evil rather than on personal preference, who have your back, and who will fight harder for you than you do for yourself. You need the support. Even Batman had Robin and Superman had Lois Lane.
Keep In Mind Who You Really Need to Please
When it comes right down to it, other people’s opinions don’t matter. You have to make your own decisions and follow your own conscience. You are accountable only to God.
So have a good cry and some chocolate. Realize that it’s always going to sting. And then pick yourself up off the floor, sit your bottom back down in your computer chair, and meet that deadline . . . and the one after that . . . and the one after that . . .
Are you following your dream or did you give it up because your friends or family didn’t approve? Are you a writer who’s faced some of these criticisms? How did you handle it?
I hope you’ll check out the books in my Busy Writer’s Guides series, including Strong Female Characters and How to Write Dialogue.
I’d love to have you sign up to receive my posts by email. All you need to do is enter your email address below and hit the “Follow” botton.
Image Credit: Sigurd Decroos (via sxc.hu)
Jan 09, 2014 @ 13:38:41
Great post! I so needed this today. For me, it isn’t the people closest to me, but the people who know me not as a writer. It does help me to remember that other people aren’t looking at my choices and decisions through the lens of my life, but through theirs. They are judging based on their values, preferences, and fears. It actually doesn’t have much to do with me. That helps me take a step back and see their words for what they really are, irrelevant to my life. Thanks for another uplifting post!
Jan 09, 2014 @ 19:39:04
Thanks for the wonderful comment! You’ve summed it all up perfectly. What they say has much more to do with their past, their preferences, biases, and fears, than it has to do with us, whether our choices are good ones, or whether we’ll be able to succeed. Looking at it that way really helps to keep things in perspective 🙂
Jan 09, 2014 @ 14:05:27
I’ve been fortunate in that no one has said aloud that I need to quit…or that what I’m doing doesn’t have merit. However, I have been on the receiving end of “the look.” You know the one–it says, “Really? Uh-huh. You just keep pretending and we’ll nod through your insanity.” My best defense are allies. I keep my writer pals close and reach out for them the second doubt, nasty attitudes, or rejections start to effect me. I think I’ve decided, 80% of this job is figuring out how to hang on to my dreams through the low spots.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 18:45:04
I had a friend say the hobby comment to me and I was dumbstruck. She is a friend, not just a coworker or an acquaintance. I told her “literary agents don’t tend to contract with hobbyists.” I wanted to set her straight that I’ve started down a path that clearly departed from my previous hobby writing. I think comments like this often source from ignorance. I don’t think she meant to be rude, she just had zero frame of reference for what writers do.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 19:29:10
Figuring out how to hang on to your dreams through the low spots really is the hardest part because even when your career is on a positive trajectory and things are going well, you’re still going to have setbacks. You’ll get a few bad reviews. Or you’ll struggle to find a work-life balance. Or a million other things. If we can just maintain perspective, though, and remember that no job is perfect, it can go a long way.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 17:37:04
I always hate the “As long as you realize it is just a hobby”. arrrrgggghhhh! No it is not a hobby, it is a dream that with enough work will be a reality. Thanks for the post!
Jan 09, 2014 @ 19:27:24
Hang in there! I think sometimes we get this kind of response from people who’ve abandoned their own dreams. They couldn’t achieve their dream or decided that they didn’t want to/it wasn’t important enough to them to pursue, and so they believe that should be the case for everyone.
Jan 10, 2014 @ 16:53:49
I’m a divorced, father of two boys. They live with me full-time. I do everything for them, work a full time job and write as well.
I think in this day and age, some men do the role previously considered a women role, as some women do a role previously considered a man role. I believe that the gender roles have not switch but splintered into more for each gender. People need to realize it isn’t an either / or decision, but which one am I doing.
I agree with Marcy. If my spouse doesn’t realize writing is important to me then we have a communication problem. I consider it a part time job not a hobby, until such time I make more money from writing than I do from my full time job. Then it’s my full time job.
It doesn’t matter if I sell anything or not, I can’t function without writing down what bounces around in my head. I can’t turn it off.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 18:42:26
This hurts my heart to know people regularly deal with people who are not supportive of the arts. I am fortunate that I am largely my own worst enemy when it comes to setting aside creative time. My husband is a musician and artist and is heavily responsible for pushing me toward larger goals of publication. He will see me writing and immediately heat up some food and put in front of my face. 🙂
The reality for many/most? of us is we have full time jobs, or we full time take care of family. Most of us seem to be doing this writing gig not as a trade-off from a paying job but in addition to it. When then results to shifting priorities for creative interests, and I think women most heavily feel this shame because shifting childcare or household tasks is seen as not fulfilling wife/mother roles and gender stereotypes. Women writers I’ve encountered through RWA (which is predominantly women) are very quick to thank husbands or partners who “let” them work on their creative endeavors. Heck, I even did that at the start of my post! It is assumed more in culture that it’s OK for men to pursue outside interests from the home when women may feel the need to seek “permission” for these tasks or risk judgement by others (or self) for doing so.
Many of us face those inner battles, and the larger lack of understanding that influences our view on our own creative output.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 19:23:26
I don’t consider myself a feminist. I consider myself an “equalist.” I believe men and woman are different but equal, and should be treated as equal. I started with that because you hit on something I think is really interesting and true. And which I find sad. In our culture, it does seem to be less acceptable for woman (and especially woman with children) to have outside interests than it is for men to have outside interests. I’ve noticed the same thing as you have that female writers tend to thank their husbands for giving them permission to follow their dreams. It’s much more rare to hear a man say the same thing.
I feel very blessed that my husband supports my choice as a valid career choice rather than as something he had to give me permission to pursue.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 18:53:30
I especially get frustrated with people who get enjoy bashing English majors. I have two degrees in writing (B.A. and M.F.A.), worked for years in public relations, and finally left to pursue writing full time. I’ve worked in a library, at a newspaper, at a magazine, and spent time in the front of the classroom as a teacher before I chose to make writing my primary occupation. I have no regrets. If you work hard at something you’re passionate about, it’s nobody’s business to tell you to “get a real job.”
*steps off soapbox*
Now that that’s out of my system… I have been blessed in many ways. My husband has always been supportive of my writing career and supported my decision to work from home as a full-time writer. I write to change people’s lives for the better–to provide hope, inspiration, and encouragement, and hopefully to entertain them along the way. What could be more important than that?
Thanks for this post, Marcy. It was much-needed in our community of writers.
Jan 09, 2014 @ 22:23:58
Amen. Thank you. A breath of refreshing air 🙂
Jan 09, 2014 @ 22:53:27
I had to laugh when I read your post — because of memories. I totally understand where you are coming from but for me it was the opposite. I was encouraged, challenged, pushed, SHOVED and finally I gave in to those that said – “You need to get serious about writing.” Finally to shut them up, I released my memoir last fall, which took 10 years to write — mostly because it was pretty intense therapy.
I know you will continue to do well — that is obvious from your post!
Jan 10, 2014 @ 00:25:31
Marcy, this was such a well-worth subject to repost. And there are many that unfortunately have to deal with this. It’s degrading. I think part of the problem is to a certain extent, the arts do not always offer a steady income. Well let me just say that in the current world that we live in there is no job security. People invest a lot of money in their education only to find out when they graduate that there are no jobs available in the field that they intended to work in. Yet, in order to be self-employed, which is what most writers are, you do need to be self-disciplined. No one is looking over your shoulder to tell you when you should be working.
The point is, we should have the prerogative to work at something that gives us joy, whether male or female. No one has the right to put us down and make us feel like a lesser person for what we do to support ourselves. It’s none of their beeswax.
I think that it’s time that I hit the chocolate and have a good cry though. Lately, I have had extreme doubt as to why I am attempting such a huge feat in writing my story. What do I hope to accomplish? Am I writing something meaningful or just wasting my time? I am discouraged, can you tell? Oh well. There’s nothing I can do but keep trying.
Thanks Marcy! 🙂
Jan 10, 2014 @ 14:49:00
I experienced this attitude from a very young age. I wrote about my experiences with it in my guest post on Joe Konrath’s blog. I have always wondered how many kid’s dreams get trampled by well meaning adults. http://jakonrath.blogspot.com.au/2013/12/guest-post-by-avril-sabine.html
Jan 10, 2014 @ 19:10:33
As a young writer, I have mixed reactions when it comes to my pursuits. On the one hand, I have very supportive family members and friends who accept and encourage my writing. They understand that even though I’m currently in university, my writing comes first. I’m very lucky on that way.
On the other hand though, I come in contact with a lot of negative opinions. When I arrived at post secondary, the first question I would be asked was “You’re in the English Program, you are going to be a teacher, right?”. And not just students. Friends of family, extended relatives, all assumed that I would teach, because that’s a respectable profession, and “everyone needs teachers”.
But the worst reactions do far have been from senior English students. When I express my commitment to writing and being published, they warn me that I need to start looking for other options, since fiction or nonfiction, I can’t live off strictly writing. It’s unsettling to think that even within my own program there is a lack of faith.
This is a wonderful article, and helps me to reaffirm that people’s negative opinions on writing are just opinions.
Jan 11, 2014 @ 16:25:36
I’m getting a late start on pursuing my writing “career”, so this was a refreshing rah-rah stream to read. Perfect boost for the new year. I write humor and started a blog to develop a following while I work on my book. One of my goals is to have a syndicated column, so it’s also a great discipline for writing tight and regularly.
My ego-bruiser comes when friends and relatives don’t seem to care enough to take the time to read your postings. You stop and ask yourself, “if I can’t get them to read it, who will?” Yet, we love what we do so we persevere.
Thanks for reminding us that may writers are in the same boat and “we get it”. Keep writing!
Jan 14, 2014 @ 17:28:56
I enjoy your posts and this was a much needed one. Thanks! Also, here’s my review on amazon. I’ve also put it on goodreads.
http://www.amazon.com/Frozen-Marcy-Kennedy-ebook/product-reviews/B00HRGOR5Y/ref=cm_cr_dp_see_all_btm?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1&sortBy=bySubmissionDateDescending